A wise guy once claimed that the traps make the man. However in today’s world, it appears that any type of formidable method of cultivate the traps rest the man. Gurus say the barbell shrugs disregard the lower traps and contribute to bad posture, specific hunched and internally rotated shoulders. Computers, video games, and lack of top quality physical education and learning don’t aid either.

You are watching: Barbell shrugs vs dumbbell shrugs

The difficulty with Shrugs

As the upper traps get all the glory, the obvious an option is the barbell shrug. However training the traps v barbell shrugs is troublesome. Native an exterior view, they’re constantly done with negative posture. Negative posture on peak of bad posture outcomes in atrocious posture. From an inside view, poor posture (and shoulder function) is a an effect of bad upward scapular rotators (the traps and also serratus anterior).

With shrugs, due to the fact that the selection of motion is small, a many weight have the right to be handled. A the majority of weight means a most strength. A lot of strength in the traps and also upward rotator sound good, yet the difficulty is that the hunched posture also primes the downward rotators the the scapulae (rhomboids and also levator scapulae) to activate. Therefore essentially, you’re break even.

Perhaps it’s ideal to discover an different exercise for structure an unyielding yoke while also keeping our shoulders functioning at your peak.


The front-squat shrug have the right to be offered with any type of loading strategy or rep scheme. Start at 135 pounds for 10 and add weight or reps indigenous there. Ns recommend a couple of weeks that hitting sets of twenty reps to element the body and also shoulder girdle for more intensive loading. This also helps you gain a feel for the lift.

I’ve however to have actually a client not have “that weird emotion in the center of your back” on this exercise. It additionally helps teach human being what scapular wall slides and similar exercises have to feel like. Give it a shot, and also start consisting of it in her training.

That’s a Wrap

Excluding all trap exercises however front-squat shrugs is extreme. Farmer’s walks, trap bar shrugs, dumbbell shrugs, even barbell shrugs space all good exercises. The upper traps acquire a poor rep sometimes, yet they play a huge duty in neck, shoulder, and also thoracic spine stabilization – something particularly important for collision and also combat athletes.

See more: Rj264 Flight Status Royal Jordanian Flight 264 Flight Tracker

Fact is, some part of the trapezius theatre a role in virtually all top body movements, for this reason it might be time to redirect your emphasis to this enormous muscle to watch improvements elsewhere in your training.