Group Decision-MakingWhat space the advantages and disadvantages of group decision-making, and how have the right to a manager boost the top quality of team decision-making?

Involving an ext people in the decision-making procedure can considerably improve the quality of a manager’s decisions and outcomes. However, involving more people can additionally increase conflict and also generate other challenges. Us turn now to the advantages and flaw of group decision-making.

You are watching: Which of the following is an advantage of group decision making?


Advantages of group Decisions

An advantage to involving teams in decision-making is that you deserve to incorporate different perspectives and ideas. Because that this advantage to be realized, however, you require a varied group. In a diverse group, the different group members will each tend to have various preferences, opinions, biases, and also stereotypes. Since a selection of viewpoints have to be negotiated and worked through, team decision-making creates additional work because that a manager, however (provided the team members reflect various perspectives) it additionally tends to minimize the impacts of bias on the outcome. For example, a rental committee made up of every men can end up hiring a bigger proportion of male applicants (simply due to the fact that they often tend to prefer world who are an ext similar to themselves). However with a rental committee consisted of of one equal number of men and women, the bias should be cancelled out, resulting in more applicants gift hired based upon their qualifications quite than your physical attributes.

Having more people associated in decision-making is likewise beneficial due to the fact that each separation, personal, instance brings unique information or expertise to the group, and also different perspectives on the problem. Additionally, having the authorized of multiple people will frequently lead to an ext options being generated and to better intellectual stimulation as team members discuss the accessible options. Brainstorming is a procedure of generating as plenty of solutions or alternatives as feasible and is a popular method associated with team decision-making.

All of these components can bring about superior outcomes when groups are associated in decision-making. Furthermore, involving world who will be influenced by a decision in the decision-making procedure will enable those individuals to have a higher understanding that the problems or problems and also a higher commitment to the solutions.


Disadvantages of team Decisions

Group decision-making is not without challenges. Part groups get bogged down by conflict, when others walk to opposing extreme and push for commitment at the price of high quality discussions. Groupthink wake up when team members select not to voice their pertains to or objections since they would rather keep the peace and also not annoy or antagonize others. Occasionally groupthink occurs since the group has a optimistic team spirit and also camaraderie, and individual team members don’t want that to readjust by presenting conflict. That can also occur since past successes have actually made the team complacent.

Often, one separation, personal, instance in the team has an ext power or exerts an ext influence 보다 others and also discourages those through differing opinions from speaking up (suppression that dissent) come ensure that only their own concepts are implemented. If members the the group are not really contributing your ideas and perspectives, however, then the group is not acquiring the services of group decision-making.


How to form a top quality Group

Effective supervisors will try to ensure quality group decision-making by creating groups with varied members so that a range of perspectives will add to the process. Lock will likewise encourage anyone to speak up and also voice your opinions and thoughts prior to the group reaching a decision. Sometimes teams will also assign a member come play the devil’s support in stimulate to mitigate groupthink. The devil’s advocate intentionally takes ~ above the role of critic. Their job is to suggest out failure logic, to challenge the group’s evaluations of various alternatives, and to recognize weaknesses in suggest solutions. This pushes the other group members come think more deeply around the benefits and disadvantages of suggest solutions prior to reaching a decision and also implementing it.


The Devils Advocate
At a conference of McDonald’s franchise owners, attorney Brian Schnell was inserted in the audience together a devil’s advocate and also often would strongly disagree through franchisee attorney Bob Zarco that the nationwide Labor relationships Board (NLRB)’s joint-employer ruling on McDonald’s is a boon because that franchisees. He would certainly raise his hand often and vehemently, i beg your pardon Zarco had actually asked him come do before the meeting. In that way, the franchisors’ articulate disagreements could it is in heard by every franchisee leader in attendance, and rebutted. Credit transaction (Mr. Blue MauMau/ flickr/ Attribution 2.0 share (CC by 2.0))

*

The techniques we’ve just defined can all aid ensure that teams reach great decisions, however what can a manager do once there is too much problem within a group? In this situation, supervisors need to help group members reduce dispute by recognize some usual ground—areas in which they have the right to agree, together as common interests, values, beliefs, experiences, or goals. Maintaining a group concentrated on a typical goal deserve to be a very worthwhile tactic come keep group members working with rather than against one another. (Figure) summarizes the methods to improve team decision-making.

Type the Decision

Technique

Benefit

Group decisions

Have diverse members in the group.

Improves quality: generates much more options, reduce bias

Assign a devil’s advocate.

Improves quality: to reduce groupthink

Encourage everyone to speak up and also contribute.

Improves quality: generates more options, stays clear of suppression the dissent

Help team members find common ground.

Improves quality: to reduce personality conflict


Conclusion

Decision-making is a crucial daily task for managers. Decisions variety from small and simple, with straightforward answers, to huge and complex, with tiny clarity around what the best selection will be. Being an efficient manager requires learning how to effectively navigate all kinds that decisions. Expertise, which creates gradually with learning and also experience, typically improves managerial decision-making, but managers seldom rely exclusively on their very own expertise. They also conduct research and also collect information from others; castle pay fist to their very own biases and to ethical implications; and they think critically about the information that they have received to do decisions that will advantage the organization and also its stakeholders.


Explain why team decision-making deserve to be much more effective 보다 individual decision-making.What space some things that can prevent teams from making an excellent decisions?As a manager, what can you execute to improve the high quality of group decision-making?
What space the advantages and defect of team decision-making, and also how deserve to a manager boost the quality of team decision-making?

Groups have the right to make far better decisions than individuals because group members have the right to contribute more knowledge and a diversity that perspectives. Groups will have tendency to generate much more options as well, which have the right to lead to far better solutions. Also, having actually people associated in make decisions the will influence them have the right to improve your attitudes about the decision the is made. However, groups sometimes fail to generate added value in the decision-making procedure as a an outcome of groupthink, conflict, or suppression that dissent.

Managers have the right to improve the high quality of group decision-making in a variety of ways. First, when developing the group, the manager must ensure the the individual group members are diverse in terms of knowledge and perspectives. The manager may also want to entrust a devil’s advocate to discourage groupthink. Managers should also encourage all group members to contribute their ideas and opinions, and they should not allow a single voice to dominate. Finally, they should not permit personality disputes to derail group processes.


Chapter review Questions

What are several of the determinants that permitted to Jen Rubio and Stephanie Korey to make great decisions as soon as they created their luggage company, Away?What space the two equipment that the brain uses in decision-making? exactly how are they pertained to programmed and nonprogrammed decisions?What is a heuristic, and when would certainly it be proper to usage a heuristic for decision-making?What is check bias? describe how it have the right to be a obstacle to reliable decision-making.What is a reasonable fallacy?What are the two varieties of conflict? which one is constructive, and which is destructive?What space the procedures in the decision-making process? Which people do people tend to skip or spend inadequate time on?What deserve to individuals carry out to boost the quality of their decision-making?What can teams or group leaders carry out to boost the high quality of group decision-making?What are the services of decision-making in a group, instead of individually?

Management an abilities Application Exercises

If you wanted to buy a brand-new car, what research would girlfriend do first to increase the likelihood of do a good decision? as a manager, perform you think friend would interact in an ext research or less research 보다 that before making huge decisions for the organization?Think about a big decision that you have made. What influence did her emotions have on the decision? walk they aid or hinder your decision-making? would you do the exact same decision again?If friend were challenged with an moral dilemma at work, that would you want to speak to for advice prior to reaching a decision?Which would certainly be better to show off a team with, a programmed or a nonprogrammed decision? Why?If you to be manager that a team with a most personality conflict, what would you do?

Managerial Decision Exercises

Imagine that you space a manager and also that 2 of your employees are blaming one another for a recent job not walking well. What factors would you take into consideration in deciding whom to believe? that else would you talk to before making a decision? What would certainly you perform to shot to reduce the likelihood that this keep going again?You have actually been asked even if it is your company should expand from selling its commodities only in north America to selling its products in Europe as well. What details would you want to collect? that would you desire to comment on the idea with prior to making a decision?You have actually a colleague who determined the organization need to pursue a brand-new technology. Ripe months right into the task of transitioning to the new technology, based on brand-new information friend are persuaded that the brand-new technology is no going to job-related out together anticipated. In fact, you suppose it to it is in a colossal failure. However, once you try to speak to her colleague around the issue, she won’t hear to your arguments. She is adamant that this brand-new technology is the exactly direction for your organization. Why do you think she is therefore resistant to seeing reason? given what you learned in this chapter, what could you do to sway her?Your manager has asked girlfriend to take it the lead on a brand-new and creative project. She has urged you to produce your own team (from currently employees) to occupational with girlfriend on the project. What factors would you want to take into consideration in deciding who should join your job team? What would you desire to carry out as the team leader to rise the likelihood the the team will it is in successful?Identify the reasonable flaw(s) in this argument:We desire to have effective leaders in this organization.Taller individuals tend come be regarded as more leader-like.Men are usually taller than women.So, we should only hire guys to be supervisors in ours organization.

Critical thinking Case


Vinyl records Make a Comeback

The music industry has seen a collection of developments that have improved audio quality—vinyl documents sales were ultimately surpassed by compact discs in the 1980s, which to be then eclipsed by digital music in the early on 2000s. Both of the more recent technologies boast superior sound quality to vinyl records. Vinyl should be dead . . . Yet it’s not. Some say this is merely a result of nostalgia—people love come harken back to enlarge times. However, part audiophiles say the vinyl records develop a “warm” sound that can’t be reproduced in any other format. In addition, a vinyl record is a tangible product (you have the right to feel it, touch it, and see it as soon as you own the physics record) and is much more attractive, indigenous an aesthetic perspective, than a CD. It is also a style that motivates listening to whole album at once, quite than simply listening to separation, personal, instance tracks, which can readjust the listening experience.

Whatever the reasons, vinyl is make an impressive comeback. Sales expansion has been in the twin digits because that the last number of years (over 50% in 2015 and also again in 2016) and also is expected to exceed $5 exchange rate in 2017. Sony, i beg your pardon hasn’t created a vinyl record because 1989, freshly announced the it is ago in the vinyl business.

One the the biggest obstacles to making vinyl documents is that most of the presses space 40+ year old. In the record-making process, vinyl bits are heated to 170 degrees, and also then a specialized machine exerts 150 lots of pressure to press the vinyl into the shape of the record. Around a dozen brand-new vinyl record manufacturers have actually sprung increase in the last decade in the unified States. Independent document Pressing, a firm based in new Jersey, began producing vinyl records in 2015 making use of old, present presses. Their goal upon beginning up to be to develop over a million records a year. Also at that level of production, though, demand far outstrips the company’s volume to produce due to the fact that of the limited number the presses available. They might run their equipments nonstop, 24 hrs a day, and also not catch up v demand.

The large question is what the future holds because that this industry. Will certainly this just be a passing fad? will the vinyl record sector remain a small niche market? Or is this the renaissance, the rejuvenation of a product that can withstand the test of time and alternative technologies? If the a rebirth, then we have to see demand proceed to thrive at that is recent quick pace . . . And if demand remains strong, then investing in new presses might well be worthwhile. If this is just a short-lived nostalgic return to an outdated media, however, climate the huge capital investment compelled to purchase new presses will never be recouped. Also with the current growth, vinyl documents still accounting for just 7% of overall music industry sales in 2015. That might be sufficient to obtain old presses running again, however so far it hasn’t been enough to promote a many investment in brand-new machines. The expense of a brand-new press? Almost half a million dollars.

At least one manufacturer is optimistic around the future that vinyl. GZ Media, based in Czechoslovakia, is currently the world’s biggest producer the vinyl records. President and owner Zdenek Pelc retained his record manufacturing facility going throughout the lean years as soon as vinyl sales bottomed out. The admits that the decision was no wholly logical; he continued in part because the an emotionally attachment to the media. After demand for vinyl records almost disappeared, Pelc kept simply a couple of of the presses to run to satisfy the need that remained. His intention was to it is in the last staying manufacturer of vinyl records. Pelc’s emotionally attachment to vinyl records seems to have actually served the well, and it’s a an excellent example the why basing decisions on pure reasonable doesn’t always lead come the best results. Consumer make purchasing decisions in component based on the emotional appeal that the product, therefore it shouldn’t be surprising that consumers likewise feel an emotional attachment come vinyl records, as Pelc did.

When demand for vinyl records was low, Pelc save the this firm presses the were no longer in usage so that they can be cannibalized for parts as needed. When sales started to thrive again in 2005, he started pulling old machines out the storage and even invest in a couple of new ones. This has actually made GZ Media not only the biggest vinyl document producer in the world, but also one that the only ones with brand-new factory equipment. GZ Media produces over 20 million vinyl documents a year, and Pelc is excited to proceed that trend and to continue to be a significant manufacturer in what is at this time still taken into consideration a niche market.

See more: Cheap Flights From Atlanta To Bwi Flights From Atlanta (Atl) To Baltimore (Bwi)


Why carry out you think vinyl documents are appealing to customers?Do you think the sales growth will proceed to be solid for vinyl sales? Why or why not?What study would you want to conduct before making a decision come invest in new presses?

Glossary

BrainstormingA procedure of generating as many concepts or choices as possible, often in groups.Devil’s advocateA group member who deliberately takes ~ above the function of being crucial of the group’s ideas in order come discourage groupthink and encourage deep thought and discussion about issues before making decisions.GroupthinkThe tendency of a team to with agreement an extremely quickly and also without substantive discussion.Suppression that dissentWhen a group member exerts his or her power to prevent others from voicing their thoughts or opinions.